There was an excellent interview with Beatrice Dillon a few issues of The Wire ago:
People say you embrace empty space in your music, where other producers might fill it with lots of stuff like effects and whatnot, that sound pleasant. Were you consciously giving yourself barriers for "Workaround"?
"Well, I've never really been into synth pads, for example, which might sound like, "So what, why are you mentioning that?" But actually that's such a massive part of electronic music is this layer of synth pads. I don't mean like chords guiding songs, necessarily.
I mean this kind of middle ground thing in the mix. it's often filled with synth pads of one type or another. And I've never really liked that. l'd either like to be listening to a song that's led by a keyboard part or a rhythm - Talking Heads is a really good example actually. I mean, if you think of, you know, the kind of "Remain in Light" era, there are some synth pads, but generally it's all very percussive and like rhythm section-kind of music with melodies and vocals on top, but there's not this middle ground thing of these synth pads. And because I don't use that, people say, "Oh, it's so empty, your music." [Laughs] And I'm like, well, it's just no synth pads.
And, you know, that's not necessarily negative, it's just that I find that when you really start to listen to contemporary music, there's this massive amount of the mix that's being filled by these synth pads. And if you take that away, then suddenly there's all this air for everything to breathe and rhythms, you hear them in a much more skeletal way because there's nothing almost pacifying the rhythms, they're just like bright bands of rhythm in space, you know?
I just wanted to make music where I was fully conscious of all the elements going into it and l wasn't just filling in layers just because, "Oh, that's what you do." You put like a reverb on something just to make it glued together. I just wanted to make music that was really bare bones and really focusing on what's happening and taking things out. And I mean, to me it's the dub approach. Things have got space around them to breathe. lt probably comes from that really~ Space for the groove and space for sound, really."
I love things like that. Where some apparently significant artistic statement just springs from arbitrary preference. From just not liking something.
It reminded me of Peter Gabriel not wanting any cymbals on his album from 1980. He told his drummers Phil Collins and Jerry Marotta they couldn't use them.
From wikipedia: "Artists given complete freedom die a horrible death...So, when you tell them what they can't do, they get creative and say, 'Oh yes I can,' which is why I banned cymbals. Phil was cool about it. [Marotta] did object and it took him a while to settle in. It's like being right-handed and having to learn to write with your left."
To make up for the missing sizzling on the record they invented "gated reverb" which became one of the most influential drum sounds ever.
I do not yet have the confidence to do that. I find it very hard not to fill everything up with sound.