Russell Davies

Semi-retiring
About | Feed | Archive

It's in the game

I'm always looking for people who've divided the world usefully into threes and here are three from John Stuart Mill. From Henry Oliver's guest post about Effective Altruism for The Ruffian.

"Mill’s work is a somewhat neglected corner of Utilitarianism that needs to be revived. In 1983, John Gray wrote a superb book called Mill on liberty: a defencein which he created a new name for Mill’s theory: indirect utilitarianism. Mill did not have, as the EAs do, a touchstone of “doing the most good” to guide his life. Rather, he lived in a state of enquiry and development, investing in three areas of life: morality (what is right), prudence (what is expedient), and aesthetic (what is noble or beautiful). The last two of those criteria often seem to be missing in Effective Altruism.

Indirect utilitarianism states that not everything is a moral question. You will not maximise happiness, Mill says, by maximising utility, but by attaching yourself to projects, people, and activities. Utility is a guiding principle for society, not a way of assessing everything we do in our lives. Get something to do, someone to love, something to enjoy, and you will become happy. Utility is not the one-and-only moral decider."

What is right. What is expedient. What is beautiful.

Projects. People. Activities.

Something to do. Someone to love. Something to enjoy.

 

January 30, 2023 in threes | Permalink

Three ingredients

@high_performance

How do you give good feedback? Head of Manchester United Academy Nick Cox with great advice 🙌🏻

♬ original sound - High Performance

September 29, 2022 in threes | Permalink

Rule of thirds

@warriorbodykyle

Follow the rule rule of thirds 🔥🔥🔥

♬ original sound - Kyle Smith

September 29, 2022 in threes | Permalink